On October 3, political analyst Ihor Chalenko discussed Vladimir Putin's address at the Valdai Club in a vlog on the Kluchokta channel. The Valdai Club serves as a platform for Moscow to shape its foreign policy messaging. Chalenko notes that this year's speech by Putin was filled with criticism of the West, claims about a multipolar world, discussion of the war in Ukraine, and Russia's economic resilience—but also featured numerous logical inconsistencies.
Putin emphasized the alleged decline of Western influence and the growing strength of BRICS nations, but at the same time highlighted how the coordination in a multipolar world poses challenges. He also discussed the economic pressure and sanctions against Russia, stressing the country’s resilience but the continued need for reforms and diversification.
Regarding Ukraine, Putin claimed not to oppose its EU accession, calling it a weakness for Europe, while simultaneously noting that a weak Europe poses threats to Russia as well—an apparently self-contradictory stance. On the subject of the war in Ukraine, he asserted a desire for peace but did not offer any concrete compromises, instead blaming Ukraine and the West for the escalation.
Chalenko pointed out other contradictions, including on economic policy (assertions of stability while raising taxes), nuclear policy (calling to extend arms treaties but also stressing Russia's nuclear superiority), and the approach to civilization and compromise between nations. Overall, the expert concludes that Putin's rhetoric is not coherent and contains conflicting messages, reflecting uncertainty in the Kremlin’s stance.
Putin's Valdai speech is described as a political performance lacking a clear plan for ending the war; the messages conveyed appear part of a controlled escalation strategy.
Ihor Chalenko invites viewers to comment on what they see as the main signals from Putin’s speech and whether Europe should prepare for new challenges.
